Are You Overpaying for Walled-Garden Ad Access?

by David Shor (Google+)
Posted on October 06, 2016 in social-media.

If your business buys video ads on Facebook, we hope you've taken note of the social network's recent mea culpa about a faulty metric that may have vastly overestimated average viewing time on the platform.

As reported in the Wall Street Journal, Facebook's metric only factored in video views of more than three seconds, when it should have included all video plays in its reporting. Though a new metric has already been issued, and the company claims the error did not impact billing, there is certainly some collateral damage that could be calculated. For example, one media-buying agency was told view times for its clients may have been overestimated by as much as 60% to 80% — and that the error has been happening for the last two years. That's a lot of ad buying decisions potentially being based on bad data.

The news is just as bad for marketers, as most rely on the accuracy of Facebook's performance projections to help them determine their ad spends on the platform, as well as the types of content they will post there.

As we see it, this is part and parcel to a much bigger issue that's at play here: performance accountability.

Considering just how instrumental Facebook has become to engaging with an audience, it's practically a given that this channel will play some part in the marketing mix for most businesses. Yet, when working with so-called "walled gardens" like Facebook or Google — which are notoriously protective when it comes to what data they will share and what tracking firms they will allow integrations with — it can be nearly impossible to get a clear picture of ad performance or of how much they are contributing to a company's overall marketing success.

See the problem?

While the full impact of Facebook's calculation error may never come to light, situations like this are why there's one marketing best practice that we at Prove feel particularly strongly about: the use of third-party verification, rather than relying on a single (and potentially biased) method of gauging marketing performance — no matter what marketing platforms, formats, or techniques you are working with.

As a marketing service provider, we want our clients to be completely confident that they are getting optimal value from every initiative we develop. That's why we rely so heavily on performance-driven techniques to power our Acqretention process — and why this technique enables us to increase ROI while keeping costs low.

If you want greater confidence that your ad budget is being spent on marketing that is custom-designed to perform to your expectations and achieve the results that you are promised, give us a call.

What's Up Next?

Construct a Mobile-First Experience That's Designed to Deliver - Delivering on audience expectations means enabling consumers to engage with your business on their terms–whenever, wherever, and however they want to connect. Learn how to enhance your digital presence so that consumers know that your business is committed to their complete satisfaction. →

About Prove

Prove is a new kind of customer acquisition, retention, technology and analytics agency. We are redefining the way marketing works, by having a single-minded focus on results. Our approach minimizes marketing risk and maximizes short-term and long-term results through a disciplined process. Our philosophy is to leverage the power of Mass Personalization to increase ROI while reducing marketing costs.

We call it Acqretention™, the process of converting an anonymous audience that is always just a click away from the competition into Connected Prospects. In this way, we support direct response results, but we retain the engagement of prospective customers who are earlier in the buying cycle.

Our approach involves a framework that ensures marketing success we call Little Bets. We get into market quickly and generate learnings through extensive testing, then go big with the winning ideas, messages, offers, channels and technologies. We'd like to do that for you.


Subscribe to receive our Prove Insights emails and new blogs.




Our custom digital marketing solutions focus on your customer acquisition & retention.


More than strategy, we provide success planning to achieve your digital business goals.


Content Marketing is the fuel behind engaging a well-understood target audience.

Contact Us Today

Let's get started


Our Physical Address
Prove LA
12910 Culver Blvd, Suite D
Los Angeles, CA 90066
P: 310-737-8600
Prove Seattle
500 E. Pike St, 2nd Floor
Seattle, WA 98122
P: 877-507-0696
Prove Dallas
2508 Highlander Way
Carrollton, TX 75006